Why does every CDC tool demo look amazing but break in production?

Because demos use clean data with perfect schemas and no edge cases. Real databases have: - Tables with 500 columns and no primary key - Schema changes that happen without warning - Batch jobs that max out connections at 3AM - Network partitions during AWS outages - Binary data that breaks JSON serialization I've never seen a demo that shows what happens when someone drops a column while CDC is running. Spoiler: most tools just die. **Reality check**: Spend 2-4 weeks testing with your actual messy data. Break things on purpose. See how each tool handles failure.

Should I use open source or pay for a managed solution?

Depends how much you like being woken up at 3AM. **Use open source (Debezium) if**: - Your team knows Kafka well enough to debug consumer lag - You enjoy spending weekends fixing broken replication - You have budget for 2+ full-time engineers to babysit it - Your company is profitable enough to absorb downtime costs **Pay for managed (Confluent Cloud, Estuary, Fivetran) if**: - You want to sleep through the night - Your engineering time is worth more than $200K/year per person - You need it working in weeks, not months - You don't want to become a Kafka expert **Reality**: Most startups pick open source to "save money," then spend 6 months getting their asses kicked by Kafka before giving up and buying the managed version they should have started with. Classic engineer move.

What's the actual total cost of this shit?

Everyone lies about CDC costs. Here's what you'll actually spend: **The "Free" Debezium Setup**: - $0 licensing (lol) - $80K/year AWS infrastructure - $300K/year for 1.5 engineers to babysit it - $200K setup cost (6 months of engineering time) - $50K/year in therapy for the on-call rotation - **Total: $630K/year** (not including the inevitable consultant) **Managed Solution (Confluent Cloud)**: - $150K/year licensing - $0 infrastructure (included) - $80K/year for 0.4 engineers to monitor it - $30K setup cost (1 month) - $0 therapy (you sleep at night) - **Total: $260K/year** **The ELT Option (Fivetran)**: - $120K/year licensing - $0 infrastructure - $40K/year for 0.2 engineers - $15K setup cost (2 weeks) - **Total: $175K/year** (if you can wait 15 minutes for updates) The "free" option costs 3x more than the expensive one. Math is a bitch.

How fast is "real-time" actually?

Marketing teams love the word "real-time." Here's what you'll actually get: **Actually Fast (50-200ms)**: - Estuary (when it works) - Custom Debezium if you know what you're doing - Confluent Cloud (expensive but consistent) **Pretty Good (500ms-5 seconds)**: - Standard Debezium setup - AWS DMS on a good day - Striim (if you can afford it) **Batch Pretending to be Real-Time (1-15 minutes)**: - Fivetran ("near real-time" = 5+ minutes) - Airbyte (getting better but still batch-focused) - Any solution that uses the word "micro-batching" **Factors that will fuck up your latency**: - Network issues between AWS regions - Your destination can't write fast enough - Schema changes that require pipeline restarts - That batch job someone runs at 3AM **Reality check**: Most businesses don't actually need sub-second latency. If you can wait 30 seconds, you can save $200K/year.

How do I migrate CDC tools without breaking everything?

CDC migration is where careers go to die. Here's how to not fuck it up: **Step 1: Run both systems for weeks** - Old and new CDC running in parallel - Compare every output obsessively - Fix discrepancies before anyone notices - Practice the cutover 10 times in staging **Step 2: Cut over during low traffic** - Start with non-critical pipelines - Have the rollback command ready to copy/paste - Monitor everything for 48 hours straight - Keep the old system running until you're sure **Step 3: Clean up the mess** - Turn off old system after 2 weeks minimum - Update all the monitoring dashboards - Document what went wrong so you remember next time **Reality**: Plan for 15-30 minutes of downtime even if everything goes perfectly. Have the rollback script ready because something always breaks.

Which tool works with my database?

**PostgreSQL**: - **Use**: Debezium if you understand logical replication - **Or**: Estuary/Fivetran if you don't want to learn - **Avoid**: Anything that doesn't handle TOAST data properly **MySQL**: - **Use**: Debezium (best binlog support) - **Or**: AWS DMS if you're already all-in on AWS - **Avoid**: Tools that break on GTID changes **MongoDB**: - **Use**: Native change streams if you can - **Or**: Debezium if you need Kafka integration - **Avoid**: Anything that can't resume after connection failures **Oracle**: - **Pay for**: Oracle GoldenGate (it's worth it) - **Or**: AWS DMS if you're migrating off Oracle anyway - **Don't**: Try to do CDC on Oracle without a DBA who knows their shit **SQL Server**: - **Use**: Built-in CDC features if you can - **Or**: AWS DMS for cloud migrations - **Avoid**: Anything that doesn't understand SQL Server transaction logs Bottom line: stick with tools that were built for your specific database. Generic solutions usually suck.

Should I build my own CDC tool?

No. **Exceptions**: - You're Netflix/Google/Facebook with 100+ engineers and unlimited budget - You have unique requirements that literally no existing tool can meet - You enjoy spending 2 years building what already exists **For everyone else**: Just buy something that works. Your time is better spent on features that make money. **The pattern**: Smart engineers think they can build better CDC. Two years later they're hiring consultants to fix their custom solution and wishing they'd just used Confluent from the start.

What's your final recommendation?

**Startups**: Use Fivetran or Airbyte. Don't overthink it. **Growing companies**: Confluent Cloud or Estuary if you need real-time. **Enterprises**: Confluent Platform with professional services. Boring but reliable. **Regulated industries**: Oracle GoldenGate. Expensive but your auditors will love it. The best CDC tool is the one that works reliably with the least operational overhead for your specific situation. Most people overthink this decision.

Currently viewing the AI version

Switch to human version

Change Data Capture (CDC) Tool Selection Guide - AI-Optimized

Critical Selection Criteria

Database Compatibility Reality Check

PostgreSQL: Version-specific logical replication differences cause production failures
- PostgreSQL 11.x vs 14+ have different logical replication slot behaviors
- Staging success on newer versions doesn't guarantee production compatibility
- TOAST data handling requirements eliminate some tools
MySQL: GTID changes break many CDC implementations
Oracle: Requires specialized expertise; generic solutions typically fail
MongoDB: Connection failure recovery capability is critical
SQL Server: Transaction log understanding mandatory

Failure Mode Planning

When CDC breaks: Network partitions, schema changes, connection pool exhaustion
Breaking points: 1M to 10M events/hour transition causes non-linear scaling failures
Market open scenarios: 10K/hour to 500K/hour in 30 seconds breaks most systems
Common failures: Kafka lag spikes (20 minutes to 1+ hour), JVM OutOfMemoryError, network buffer saturation

Tool Categories and Real Costs

Category	Examples	Annual Cost	Engineering Overhead	Recovery Time	Real-Time Capability
Open Source	Debezium, Kafka Connect	$400K-800K	1.5-2 FTE engineers	Hours to days	50-200ms (if configured correctly)
Managed Cloud	Confluent Cloud, Estuary	$200K-600K	0.4 FTE engineers	Minutes to hours	50ms-5 seconds
Enterprise	Confluent Platform, Striim	$600K-1.5M	0.8 FTE engineers	Hours	500ms-5 seconds
ELT with CDC	Fivetran, Airbyte	$150K-500K	0.2 FTE engineers	Minutes	1-15 minutes
Database-Native	AWS DMS, Oracle GoldenGate	$200K-700K	0.6 FTE engineers	Variable	500ms-5 seconds

Hidden Cost Factors

Debezium "free" reality: $630K/year including infrastructure and engineering time
Consultant rescue costs: $60K-120K for emergency fixes
Compliance requirements: Add $1M+ for regulated industries
Migration downtime: 15-30 minutes minimum even with perfect execution

Industry-Specific Requirements

Financial Services

Mandatory: Audit trails, Oracle GoldenGate compliance features
Cost reality: $50K/year licensing justified by regulatory requirements
Failure consequence: Demo failures during funding rounds

E-commerce

Critical failure point: Black Friday traffic spikes
Scale requirement: Auto-scaling capability for 50x traffic increases
Inventory sync: Sub-minute latency required for stock accuracy

Healthcare

Constraint: HIPAA compliance eliminates 50% of options
Requirement: Data residency rules eliminate additional 50%
Solution: On-premises implementations cost 3x cloud alternatives
Audit necessity: Comprehensive logging and PII redaction

Startups

Recommendation: Managed solutions (Fivetran, Airbyte)
Rationale: Engineering time worth more than licensing costs
Timeline: Weeks to implementation vs. months for self-managed

Performance Specifications

Latency Categories

Actually Fast (50-200ms): Estuary, custom Debezium, Confluent Cloud
Production Acceptable (500ms-5s): Standard Debezium, AWS DMS
Batch Disguised (1-15 minutes): Fivetran, Airbyte

Scale Breaking Points

1M events/hour: Most tools handle adequately
10M events/hour: Non-linear scaling failures begin
Network saturation: Buffers fill, Kafka drops messages
Connection exhaustion: Database connection pools max out

Tool-Specific Operational Intelligence

Debezium

Strengths: Best PostgreSQL binlog support, extensive customization
Weaknesses: Requires Kafka expertise, complex operational overhead
Critical requirement: Understanding of consumer lag debugging
Failure modes: Schema evolution breaks, TOAST data handling issues

Confluent Cloud

Strengths: Managed Kafka expertise, 24/7 support
Cost multiplier: 5x more than self-managed but includes operational expertise
Latency: Consistent sub-100ms performance
Support quality: Actually answers calls during outages

AWS DMS

Strengths: Integration with AWS ecosystem
Weaknesses: Hit-or-miss support quality, Oracle limitations
Best use case: Cloud migration scenarios
Failure pattern: Random weekend failures

Fivetran

Strengths: Plug-and-play simplicity, comprehensive connector library
Latency limitation: 5+ minutes typical, marketing claims "near real-time"
Cost efficiency: $175K/year total cost vs. $630K for Debezium
Trade-off: Acceptable for most business cases not requiring true real-time

Critical Implementation Warnings

Schema Evolution Handling

Failure scenario: Column drops during CDC operation cause tool deaths
Testing requirement: Simulate schema changes during load testing
Recovery necessity: Pipeline restart capabilities

Network Partition Recovery

Test requirement: Simulate connection failures during evaluation
Critical capability: Automatic reconnection and resume functionality
Monitoring necessity: Consumer lag alerting systems

Migration Strategy

Dual-system period: Run old and new systems in parallel for weeks
Comparison verification: Every output must match between systems
Rollback preparation: Copy/paste ready rollback commands
Timeline expectation: 15-30 minute downtime minimum

Decision Framework

Evaluation Process

Real data testing: 2-4 weeks with production data volumes, not demo datasets
Failure simulation: Network kills, CPU saturation, schema changes
Total cost calculation: Include engineering time, infrastructure, support
Reference customer interviews: Contact users not on vendor reference lists
Rollback planning: Prepare for first choice failure

Immediate Disqualifiers

No production references in your industry
Inability to handle your database version
No schema evolution support
Vendor acquisition in progress
No 24/7 support for critical systems

Team Capability Assessment

Kafka expertise available: Consider Debezium
No Kafka knowledge: Mandatory managed solution
Limited engineering bandwidth: ELT tools with CDC features
Compliance requirements: Enterprise solutions only

Market Consolidation Impact

Recent Acquisitions

IBM acquired StreamSets ($2.3B, December 2023)
Qlik acquired Talend (via Thoma Bravo $2.4B, 2021)
Databricks acquired Arcion ($100M, October 2023)

Selection Strategy

Avoid mid-size acquisition targets unless prepared for transition disruption
Choose vendors: Too big to kill or too small to matter
Expect: Pricing increases post-acquisition, support quality degradation

Technology Trends to Ignore

AI-powered CDC: Mostly marketing, basic alerting rebranded
Edge CDC: IoT-specific, irrelevant for most use cases
Vector database CDC: AI embedding updates, niche application

Compliance and Regulatory Requirements

HIPAA (Healthcare)

Mandatory features: Automatic audit trails, PII redaction, encryption
Eliminated options: Most open-source tools lack compliance features
Recommended: Oracle GoldenGate despite $2M+ cost
Audit preparation: Comprehensive logging requirements

GDPR (European Operations)

Data residency: Geographic restrictions eliminate cloud options
Processing transparency: Audit trail requirements
Right to erasure: Data deletion capability across CDC pipeline

SOX (Financial Services)

Change control: All CDC modifications must be auditable
Segregation of duties: Admin access controls
Data integrity: Guaranteed consistency requirements

Resource Requirements and Expertise

Self-Managed Solutions (Debezium)

Engineering time: 1.5-2 FTE for maintenance
Setup duration: 3-6 months to production-ready
Expertise required: Kafka internals, consumer lag debugging
On-call burden: 24/7 coverage for critical systems
Infrastructure cost: $80K+/year AWS/cloud hosting

Managed Solutions

Engineering time: 0.2-0.4 FTE for monitoring
Setup duration: 1-4 weeks to production
Expertise required: Basic configuration, vendor relationship management
Support included: 24/7 vendor support with SLAs
Total cost: Often lower than self-managed when engineering time included

Migration Expertise Requirements

Dual-system management: Parallel operation capabilities
Data validation: Output comparison and verification
Rollback execution: Emergency procedure implementation
Monitoring setup: Comprehensive observability during transition

This technical reference provides structured, actionable intelligence for CDC tool selection, focusing on real-world implementation challenges and operational requirements rather than marketing claims.

Useful Links for Further Investigation

Resources That Actually Matter (Not Marketing Bullshit)

Link	Description
Debezium Documentation	The only docs that explain why your Kafka consumer is lagging without trying to sell you something. Skip the "concepts" section and go straight to the connector docs - that's where the real gotchas live.
Confluent Platform Documentation	Expensive but thorough. Their monitoring section is gold when your cluster's on fire at 2am. The ksqlDB stuff is overhyped but the Connect docs are solid.
Estuary Flow Documentation	Actually readable docs from a company that knows real-time isn't just marketing speak. Their error handling examples are what every vendor should provide.
AWS Database Migration Service Guide	AWS documentation that doesn't completely suck. The troubleshooting section will save your ass when DMS decides to randomly fail on a weekend.
Airbyte Connector Catalog	Hit-or-miss depending on the connector, but at least they're honest about what's broken. Check the GitHub issues before you commit to anything.
Gartner Magic Quadrant for Data Integration Tools	Costs $3K to read but actually useful for understanding who's buying who next. Skip the "vision" bullshit and focus on the execution scores.
Estuary: The Change Data Capture Landscape	Biased toward their own tool but honest about what's broken in the market. Actually written by engineers, not marketing.
Striim: What is Change Data Capture	Generic overview but decent if you need to explain CDC to your manager without using the word "fuck."
Martin Kleppmann's "Designing Data-Intensive Applications"	The book every engineer pretends to have read. Chapters 5 and 11 are genuinely useful for understanding why CDC is harder than it looks.
Hevo Data: Debezium vs Kafka Connect	Decent comparison that doesn't try to sell you their platform. The architecture diagrams actually make sense.
Infinite Lambda: Postgres CDC with Debezium	Step-by-step guide that works if you follow it exactly. Deviate at your own risk - PostgreSQL logical replication is finicky as hell.
Debezium Examples Repository	The examples that should work but half of them are broken on the latest version. Start with the simple ones and pray.
Stream Processing Benchmarks	Yahoo's benchmark suite for comparing streaming platforms, including CDC throughput and latency measurements.
TPC-C CDC Benchmarks	Industry-standard database benchmarks that can be used for CDC performance evaluation across different tools.
Confluent Performance Testing	Comprehensive guide to performance testing Kafka-based CDC implementations, including methodology and tooling.
AWS Pricing Calculator	Platform-specific calculators for estimating infrastructure costs: AWS DMS and Kinesis pricing, Google Cloud Dataflow cost estimation, Azure Data Factory pricing models.
Confluent Platform Pricing	Detailed pricing information for managed Kafka and CDC services with cost estimation tools.
ScyllaDB CDC Cost Analysis	Cost-benefit analysis for implementing CDC with ScyllaDB including performance benchmarks.
Debezium Zulip Chat	Active community forum for Debezium users with real-time support from core maintainers and experienced users.
Confluent Community Slack	Large community of Kafka and CDC practitioners sharing experiences and troubleshooting advice.
DataTalks.Club Community	Active data engineering community with over 20,000 members discussing CDC tools, implementation experiences, and tool comparisons. Join their Slack workspace for real-time discussions about CDC challenges and recommendations.
Stack Overflow CDC Tags	Searchable Q&A database with solutions to common CDC implementation challenges.
DB-Engines Database Ranking	Independent ranking of database systems including those with native CDC capabilities.
Apache Software Foundation Incubator Projects	Information about emerging open-source CDC projects and their maturity levels.
CNCF Landscape: Streaming & Messaging	Cloud Native Computing Foundation's catalog of streaming and messaging tools including CDC platforms.
Database Migration Best Practices	AWS collection of migration guides and best practices applicable across different CDC tools and platforms.
Palantir CDC Core Concepts	Comprehensive guide covering CDC concepts and enterprise implementation patterns.
Microsoft SQL Server CDC Documentation	Official Microsoft documentation for SQL Server CDC implementation and best practices.
GDPR Compliance for Data Streaming	Legal framework requirements that impact CDC tool selection for European operations.
AICPA SOC 2 Reports	AICPA framework for evaluating security controls in CDC and data integration platforms.
HIPAA Security Rule Updates 2025	Comprehensive overview of HIPAA Security Rule compliance requirements and 2025 updates for healthcare data streaming and CDC implementations, including new cybersecurity requirements.
Confluent Training Courses	Professional training programs covering Kafka, Connect, and CDC best practices with certification options.
Apache Kafka Certification Programs	Industry-recognized certifications for streaming and messaging platforms including CDC-specific content.
Cloud Provider Training	Platform-specific training for cloud-native CDC solutions: AWS Database Migration Service training, Google Cloud Dataflow certification, Azure Data Factory learning paths.

Change Data Capture (CDC) Tool Selection Guide - AI-Optimized

Critical Selection Criteria

Database Compatibility Reality Check

Failure Mode Planning

Tool Categories and Real Costs

Hidden Cost Factors

Industry-Specific Requirements

Financial Services

E-commerce

Healthcare

Startups

Performance Specifications

Latency Categories

Scale Breaking Points

Tool-Specific Operational Intelligence

Debezium

Confluent Cloud

AWS DMS

Fivetran

Critical Implementation Warnings

Schema Evolution Handling

Network Partition Recovery

Migration Strategy

Decision Framework

Evaluation Process

Immediate Disqualifiers

Team Capability Assessment

Market Consolidation Impact

Recent Acquisitions

Selection Strategy

Technology Trends to Ignore

Compliance and Regulatory Requirements

HIPAA (Healthcare)

GDPR (European Operations)

SOX (Financial Services)

Resource Requirements and Expertise

Self-Managed Solutions (Debezium)

Managed Solutions

Migration Expertise Requirements

Useful Links for Further Investigation

Resources That Actually Matter (Not Marketing Bullshit)

Related Tools & Recommendations

MongoDB vs PostgreSQL vs MySQL: Which One Won't Ruin Your Weekend

Why I Finally Dumped Cassandra After 5 Years of 3AM Hell

I Survived Our MongoDB to PostgreSQL Migration - Here's How You Can Too

MySQL Replication - How to Keep Your Database Alive When Shit Goes Wrong

MySQL Alternatives That Don't Suck - A Migration Reality Check

Kafka Will Fuck Your Budget - Here's the Real Cost

Apache Kafka - The Distributed Log That LinkedIn Built (And You Probably Don't Need)

Debezium - Database Change Capture Without the Pain

AWS Database Migration Service - When You Need to Move Your Database Without Getting Fired

Oracle GoldenGate - Database Replication That Actually Works

Fivetran: Expensive Data Plumbing That Actually Works

Airbyte - Stop Your Data Pipeline From Shitting The Bed

Striim - Enterprise CDC That Actually Doesn't Suck

Databricks vs Snowflake vs BigQuery Pricing: Which Platform Will Bankrupt You Slowest

Snowflake - Cloud Data Warehouse That Doesn't Suck

dbt + Snowflake + Apache Airflow: Production Orchestration That Actually Works

MongoDB Alternatives: Choose the Right Database for Your Specific Use Case

Kafka + MongoDB + Kubernetes + Prometheus Integration - When Event Streams Break

MongoDB Alternatives: The Migration Reality Check

jQuery - The Library That Won't Die