How long will this migration actually take?

If someone gives you a timeline, multiply by 3. If they say 6 months, expect 18 months. If they say 12 months, update your LinkedIn because you'll be looking for a new job in 2 years. Our first "simple" service extraction took 4 months instead of 3 weeks. We spent 2 weeks just figuring out why authentication was broken. The database migration alone took 6 weeks because we found references in 14 places we didn't know existed. Netflix took 7 years, but Netflix had unlimited budget and the best engineers in the world. Your company is not Netflix. **Reality check:** Small service (< 10K lines): 3-6 months. Medium service (50K lines): 6-12 months. Large service: cancel your vacation plans for the next 2 years.

Should I migrate everything or give up halfway through?

Don't migrate everything. Seriously. Keep your core business logic as a monolith and only extract services that actually benefit from being separate. We extracted 12 services from our monolith. 8 of them should have stayed in the monolith. The user preferences service that we spent 3 months extracting? It gets called by one other service and changes once every 6 months. Completely pointless. **Keep as monolith:** - Anything that shares complex business logic - Services that are called by everything else - Code that changes together - Features your team of 5 people can easily manage **Extract as microservice:** - Third-party integrations (payment, email, etc.) - Scaling bottlenecks (if you actually have them) - Features owned by separate teams

How do I handle transactions when everything is distributed?

You don't. You rewrite your business logic to not need distributed transactions. This is harder than it sounds and will require changing how your application works. The saga pattern sounds great until you try to implement rollback logic for 6 different services and realize you need to handle partial failures, timeouts, and duplicate messages. We spent 4 months building a saga framework that would have been a 5-line database transaction in the monolith. **What actually works:** - Avoid distributed transactions entirely - Design your services to be idempotent - Accept that some data will be eventually consistent - Build reconciliation processes to fix inconsistencies

What happens when services start failing randomly?

Everything breaks. That's not a hypothetical - it's a guarantee. Your user service will go down at 2am on Sunday. Your authentication service will start timing out during the Black Friday rush. Your database will hit connection limits because now you have 15 services all opening connections. Circuit breakers help but you need to implement them correctly and test them. Ours didn't work the first time because we forgot to handle the case where the fallback also fails. **War story:** Our payment service went down during a product launch. The Hystrix circuit breaker kicked in and started returning HTTP 200 with "payment successful" for all requests without actually charging anyone. Took us 6 hours to discover because the logs showed "success" status. We lost $73,412 in revenue before someone checked the Stripe dashboard.

How do I avoid creating 47 microservices that do nothing useful?

Easy - don't extract services because you can. Extract them because you have to. We created a "notification service" because microservices architecture said we should. It had 3 API endpoints and 200 lines of code. It took more time to deploy and monitor than the original inline notification code. **Red flags you're over-microservicing:** - Your service has fewer than 500 lines of code - It's called by only one other service - You can't explain why it needs to be separate - The team that "owns" it spends 10 minutes per month on it

What's the dumbest mistake you can make?

Starting with authentication. Do not extract your auth service first. When auth breaks, everyone gets logged out and your CEO will ask why the entire application is down. We did this. Auth0 authentication started failing for edge cases we hadn't tested - users with special characters in email addresses got "invalid_request" errors. Password reset broke because the reset service couldn't validate tokens from the login service. Google OAuth stopped working with "redirect_uri_mismatch" errors. It took 3 days to debug because the logs were spread across 4 different services and none of them had correlation IDs. **Other ways to destroy your career:** - Migrating your core business logic first - Not having monitoring before you start - Assuming your tests cover all the edge cases - Doing a big bang migration because "it's faster"

How do I sell this disaster to leadership?

Don't. If your monolith works, keep it. But if management insists, focus on problems you actually have: - "We can't deploy features fast enough" (if true) - "We need to scale individual components" (if you actually need to) - "We want teams to work independently" (if your org structure supports it) Don't say: - "It will be easier to maintain" (it won't) - "We'll ship features faster" (you won't, at least not for 18 months) - "It's more scalable" (irrelevant if you don't have scale problems)

How do I handle authentication across 15 different services?

Very carefully and with lots of testing. JWT tokens work until you need to revoke them. Then you need a token blacklist service. Then you need to handle token refresh. Then you need to sync token validation across all services. OAuth is the "standard" but every OAuth provider implements it differently. Auth0 is expensive but works. Keycloak is free but you'll spend 6 months figuring out how to configure it properly. **What broke for us:** - JWT validation added 847ms latency to every request because we were calling Auth0's userinfo endpoint - Service-to-service auth failed with "RSA signature verification failed" and we couldn't figure out which service had the wrong public key - Logout didn't work properly across services - users stayed logged in to 3 out of 7 services - Password reset tokens expired after 1 hour on the main service but 24 hours on the admin service

What skills do we actually need for this to not be a complete shitshow?

You need someone who's debugged distributed systems in production at 3am. Not someone who's read about microservices or taken a course. Someone who's been there when everything breaks. **Must-have skills:** - Docker troubleshooting (not just building images) - Kubernetes debugging (not just deploying pods) - Understanding of eventual consistency (not just the theory) - Experience with service discovery failures - Knowledge of circuit breaker patterns in practice **Nice-to-have skills:** - Patience to explain to stakeholders why everything takes longer - Ability to say "no" when asked to extract every piece of functionality - Strong networking knowledge for debugging connectivity issues - Experience with message queue operational failures If you don't have these skills on your team, hire someone who does or abandon the migration. Reading blog posts is not the same as operational experience.

Currently viewing the AI version

Switch to human version

Microservices Migration: AI-Optimized Technical Reference

Executive Summary

Reality Check: Microservices migration takes 18-24 months minimum for non-trivial applications. Netflix took 7 years with unlimited budget and world-class engineers. Your e-commerce site with 50 concurrent users does not need Netflix's architecture.

Cost Impact: AWS bills typically increase from $2K to $15K monthly. Authentication becomes distributed nightmare. Debugging becomes exponentially harder with distributed traces.

Prerequisites (Non-Negotiable Requirements)

Infrastructure Requirements

Monitoring Stack (Critical - Setup Before Migration)

Distributed Tracing: Jaeger 1.38+ (2-day setup for span correlation)
Centralized Logging: ELK Stack 7.8+ or Grafana Loki
- Elasticsearch 7.8.0 memory issues: Requires 32GB+ for log ingestion spikes
- Error pattern: "CircuitBreakerService: [parent] Data too large"
Metrics: Prometheus 2.40 + Grafana 9.3
- PromQL query complexity: rate(http_requests_total[5m]) requires 6+ hours debugging time
APM Tools: Datadog or New Relic (expensive but functional out-of-box)

CI/CD Pipeline Requirements

Individual build/test/deploy per microservice
Jenkins 2.401.3 issues: OutOfMemoryError with 8 concurrent builds on 2GB RAM
GitLab CI: 847-line YAML files, complex but manageable
GitHub Actions: Simple but poor Docker layer caching

Team Skills (Requirements Not Suggestions)

Docker networking troubleshooting at 3AM
Kubernetes YAML debugging without panic attacks
Eventual consistency understanding (theory insufficient)
Service discovery failure experience

Financial Reality Check

Migration Costs:

Timeline: 18-24 months (multiply estimates by 3x)
Infrastructure: 40% AWS cost increase during parallel running
Personnel: 3+ contractors typically required
Opportunity cost: Core business feature development stops

Migration Process

Phase 1: Traffic Control Setup

Proxy Layer Selection

NGINX: Complex configuration, 400-line files common
- Failure mode: "400 Bad Request" with zero useful logging
AWS ALB: $22/month per load balancer, scales automatically
Kong: Requires Lua expertise, plugin development challenging

First Service Selection Criteria

DO START WITH: Read-only services (admin dashboards, reporting)
DO NOT START WITH: Authentication (breaks login), Payments (revenue loss), Core business logic (user-visible failures)

Phase 2: Service Implementation

Database Per Service Pattern

Critical: No shared databases between services
Failure Case: PostgreSQL 13 deadlocks every 20 minutes
Schema Coordination: Migration conflicts between Rails 6.1 and Spring Boot 2.7

API Versioning (Mandatory From Day One)

Pattern: Use /v1/users not /users
Failure Cost: 8-service deployment coordination without versioning

Phase 3: Traffic Migration

Gradual Rollout Schedule

5% traffic for 1 week (basic bugs: NullPointerException)
10% traffic for 1 week (load bugs: connection pool exhaustion)
25% traffic for 1 week (race conditions: ConcurrentModificationException)
50% traffic for 2 weeks (subtle bugs: timezone issues)
100% only after confidence in 3AM stability

Circuit Breaker Implementation

Tools: resilience4j (Hystrix deprecated 2018)
Critical Failure Mode: Returning false success status during fallback

Technology Stack Analysis

Container Orchestration

Tool	Learning Curve	Operational Complexity	When to Use
Kubernetes 1.28	3 months additional timeline	High - requires dedicated expertise	Teams with K8s experience
Docker Swarm	2 weeks	Low - but limited ecosystem	Small teams, simple requirements

API Gateway Comparison

Tool	Cost	Complexity	Failure Modes
AWS API Gateway	$1,200/month moderate traffic	Low management	2-second cold starts
Kong	Free (OSS)	High - Lua required	Plugin development expertise scarce
NGINX	Low	Medium-High	Configuration file complexity

Database Selection

PostgreSQL 15 (Recommended Default)

ACID transactions functional
JSON support adequate
Performance predictable with proper indexes
DBA expertise widely available

MongoDB 6.0 (Avoid for Complex Queries)

Document storage appealing in theory
47-line aggregation queries replace 3-line SQL
Data loss during balancer migrations (3-hour user data loss experienced)

Message Queue Reality

Apache Kafka 3.3

Use Case: Millions of events daily
Operational Cost: Requires Java experts team
Failure Mode: "ZooKeeper ensemble not ready" - 4-hour outages

RabbitMQ

Use Case: 99% of message queue needs
Operational Complexity: Manageable clustering
Reliability: Consistent performance

Critical Failure Modes

Authentication Service Extraction

Impact: CEO-level visibility when login fails system-wide
Specific Failures:

Special characters in email addresses: "invalid_request" errors
Password reset service token validation failures
Google OAuth "redirect_uri_mismatch" errors
Debug time: 3 days across 4 services without correlation IDs

Data Consistency Issues

Distributed Transaction Reality: Saga pattern requires rollback logic for 6+ failure modes
War Story: Payment service circuit breaker returned false success during outage

Revenue loss: $73,412 before Stripe dashboard verification
Detection time: 6 hours (logs showed "success" status)

Service Communication Failures

JWT Validation Latency: 847ms added per request calling Auth0 userinfo endpoint
Service-to-Service Auth: "RSA signature verification failed" - unknown service key issues
Cross-Service Logout: Users remained logged in to 3/7 services

Decision Framework

When NOT to Migrate (Hard Stops)

Working monolith with manageable team
No 24/7 operations capability
Team lacks production Docker experience
Migration reason: "want modern technology" or "easier maintenance"

Service Extraction Criteria

Extract Only If:

Third-party integrations (payment, email)
Proven scaling bottlenecks
Separate team ownership requirements

Keep as Monolith:

Shared business logic
Code that changes together
Services called by everything
Team size under 10 people

Over-Microservicing Red Flags

Services under 500 lines of code
Single-caller services
Unable to explain separation necessity
Team maintenance under 10 minutes monthly

Resource Requirements

Timeline Multipliers

Small service (<10K lines): 3-6 months
Medium service (50K lines): 6-12 months
Large service: 2+ years

Team Skill Requirements

Must Have (Not Nice-to-Have):

Production distributed systems debugging experience
Kubernetes operational troubleshooting
Circuit breaker pattern implementation experience
Service discovery failure resolution

Operational Knowledge Gaps Cost:

22-month timeline instead of 4-month estimate
3 contractor additions mid-project
Multiple production rollbacks

Success Metrics

Technical Success Indicators

Sub-100ms service-to-service latency
99.9% circuit breaker functionality
Zero authentication service failures
Complete request tracing across services

Business Success Criteria

No revenue-impacting authentication failures
Deployment independence without coordination
Team autonomy without cross-service debugging
Infrastructure cost increase under 50%

Failure Warning Signs

3+ major rollbacks in first 6 months
Service count exceeding team count by 3x
Debug sessions requiring 4+ service log correlation
Authentication issues requiring CEO escalation

This technical reference provides decision-making criteria, implementation patterns, and failure mode prevention for microservices migration based on operational experience rather than theoretical best practices.

Microservices Migration: AI-Optimized Technical Reference

Executive Summary

Prerequisites (Non-Negotiable Requirements)

Infrastructure Requirements

Financial Reality Check

Migration Process

Phase 1: Traffic Control Setup

Phase 2: Service Implementation

Phase 3: Traffic Migration

Technology Stack Analysis

Container Orchestration

API Gateway Comparison

Database Selection

Message Queue Reality

Critical Failure Modes

Authentication Service Extraction

Data Consistency Issues

Service Communication Failures

Decision Framework

When NOT to Migrate (Hard Stops)

Service Extraction Criteria

Over-Microservicing Red Flags

Resource Requirements

Timeline Multipliers

Team Skill Requirements

Success Metrics

Technical Success Indicators

Business Success Criteria

Failure Warning Signs

Related Tools & Recommendations

GitOps Integration Hell: Docker + Kubernetes + ArgoCD + Prometheus

Kafka + MongoDB + Kubernetes + Prometheus Integration - When Event Streams Break

Prometheus + Grafana + Jaeger: Stop Debugging Microservices Like It's 2015

Set Up Microservices Monitoring That Actually Works

RAG on Kubernetes: Why You Probably Don't Need It (But If You Do, Here's How)

Docker Alternatives That Won't Break Your Budget

I Tested 5 Container Security Scanners in CI/CD - Here's What Actually Works

Why I Finally Dumped Cassandra After 5 Years of 3AM Hell

GitHub Actions + Docker + ECS: Stop SSH-ing Into Servers Like It's 2015

MongoDB vs PostgreSQL vs MySQL: Which One Won't Ruin Your Weekend

Grafana - The Monitoring Dashboard That Doesn't Suck

MongoDB Alternatives: Choose the Right Database for Your Specific Use Case

containerd - The Container Runtime That Actually Just Works

Podman Desktop - Free Docker Desktop Alternative

I Survived Our MongoDB to PostgreSQL Migration - Here's How You Can Too

Maven is Slow, Gradle Crashes, Mill Confuses Everyone

GitHub Actions Marketplace - Where CI/CD Actually Gets Easier

GitHub Actions Alternatives That Don't Suck

OpenTelemetry + Jaeger + Grafana on Kubernetes - The Stack That Actually Works

Redis vs Memcached vs Hazelcast: Production Caching Decision Guide