Been using both Adminer and phpMyAdmin since 2018. Adminer is basically phpMyAdmin's lighter, faster cousin that supports more databases. Here's what you actually need to know.
The Reality: It's Just Better
Adminer is one PHP file, around 500KB. phpMyAdmin is 13MB+ of files. Both manage databases, but Adminer doesn't make you wait 5 seconds for every page load.
On my dev box, Adminer loads table views fast enough that I don't want to punch the screen. phpMyAdmin makes me consider switching to command line for everything. Three other devs I know switched after getting tired of waiting 30 seconds for every goddamn page load. Way more responsive when you're debugging production at 2am and already hate everything.
The official docs have performance comparisons, and most MySQL GUI reviews rank it well.
Database Support That Actually Matters
Works with the databases you're probably using:
Out of the box:
- MySQL/MariaDB (obviously)
- PostgreSQL
- SQLite (great for dev/testing)
- SQL Server (if you're stuck with Windows)
- Oracle (if you hate yourself and love suffering)
With plugins:
- MongoDB (though you should probably use Compass)
- Elasticsearch (basic support)
Most web apps use MySQL or PostgreSQL anyway. Adminer handles both without the "MySQL-only" bullshit that makes phpMyAdmin completely fucking useless for PostgreSQL projects.
Security That Actually Works
Adminer isn't perfect - patched it twice last year for XSS issues. But phpMyAdmin's security record is Swiss cheese with new CVEs every few months. Adminer at least has decent defaults:
Rate limiting on login attempts (stops brute force). No blank passwords allowed (forces authentication). Smaller codebase = fewer attack vectors. Updates that don't break everything.
CVE database shows a few vulnerabilities including SSRF and XSS issues. Keep it updated and follow security practices.
Still, don't be an idiot - put it behind HTTP auth or firewall it. Any web-based database tool is a security risk if left wide open.
What Sucks About It
Let's be honest about the downsides:
Interface is different from phpMyAdmin - takes getting used to. Fewer themes and plugins. Some features buried in menus. Documentation gaps mean I still Google basic stuff. MySQL Workbench beats it for complex query analysis.
Can't just drop it on any server. Had one shared host where it wouldn't work - their custom PHP restrictions blocked mysqli_connect()
by default. Took 3 support tickets to figure that out.
For simple database management though? Adminer wins. Upload file, connect, get work done. No dependency hell or config nightmares.