Currently viewing the human version
Switch to AI version

Why Redux Exists (And Why You'll Hate It, Then Love It)

Redux solves the problem of "I have no fucking clue why this component updated when I clicked that button over there." It forces all state changes through a predictable flow: action → reducer → new state → component updates. Sounds simple, right? It is, once you get past the learning curve from hell.

The Core Concepts (That Will Confuse You for a Week)

Redux has three rules that seem obvious until you try to implement them:

  1. Single source of truth - All your state lives in one object tree. No more hunting through 47 different components to find where that user data is stored.
  2. State is read-only - You can't just mutate state directly. You have to dispatch an action. Yes, even for a simple counter increment. No, that's not overkill once your app gets complex.
  3. Changes are made with pure functions - Reducers take current state + action and return new state. No side effects, no API calls, no bullshit.

The Redux data flow goes: Component dispatches action → Store runs reducer → Store notifies components → Components re-render with new state. Every state change is traceable, which is why Redux DevTools can do time travel debugging.

Redux Data Flow Diagram

Redux Toolkit: The Thing That Actually Fixed Redux

Redux Toolkit Logo

Redux used to require writing 50 lines of boilerplate to add a fucking counter. Redux Toolkit fixed that nightmare. RTK's `createSlice` generates action creators and reducers automatically, and `configureStore` sets up your store with sane defaults.

Before RTK: Writing action types, action creators, and reducers separately like some kind of masochist. Also praying you didn't typo your action type string because "INCREMENT" vs "INCREMNET" will make you question your career choices.
After RTK: Define your logic once in a slice, get everything generated for you.

Current Status: Redux Actually Doesn't Suck Anymore

Redux DevTools Interface

Redux Unidirectional Data Flow

Redux 5.0 and Redux Toolkit 2.0 were released on December 4, 2023, not some mythical "late 2024" date. The new versions include proper TypeScript support (finally), better ESM compatibility, and performance improvements.

Companies like Facebook still use Redux because migrating 50,000 components is harder than learning Kubernetes. I saw one team try to migrate away from Redux - 6 months later they gave up and went back after hitting a race condition bug that would've been trivial to debug with Redux DevTools. New projects can choose Redux Toolkit for the better developer experience, or alternatives like Zustand if they want simpler state management without the Redux ceremony.

Redux vs The Things You're Probably Considering Instead

What Actually Matters

Redux + RTK

Zustand

Context API

MobX

Learning Curve

Expect to hate it for 2 weeks

Weekend project

If you know React, you know this

Feels magical until it breaks

Debugging

Redux DevTools are godlike

console.log is your friend

Good luck finding where state broke

MobX DevTools exist but...

Performance

Fast if you use selectors right

Fast out of the box

Re-renders everything like crazy

Fast until you fuck up observables

Bundle Size

47KB (worth it for complex apps)

8KB (tiny)

0KB (built-in)

76KB (chunky)

When State Gets Complex

Shines here

Good luck debugging

You're fucked

Hope the magic keeps working

Redux Toolkit: How Redux Stopped Being Terrible

Redux Toolkit is what Redux should have been from day one. Before RTK, adding a simple counter to your app required creating action types, action creators, and reducers separately. RTK's `createSlice` does all that in one function. It's not revolutionary, it's just common sense.

The Before Times (Don't Do This Anymore)

Old Redux was a fucking nightmare of boilerplate:

// Action types (why?)
const INCREMENT = 'counter/increment'

// Action creators (seriously?)
const increment = () => ({ type: INCREMENT })

// Reducer (finally, actual logic)
const counterReducer = (state = { value: 0 }, action) => {
  switch (action.type) {
    case INCREMENT:
      return { value: state.value + 1 }
    default:
      return state
  }
}

That's 10+ lines for a counter increment. RTK does the same thing in 3 lines.

RTK: Actually Usable Redux

Redux Toolkit generates the boilerplate for you:

import { createSlice } from '@reduxjs/toolkit'

const counterSlice = createSlice({
  name: 'counter',
  initialState: { value: 0 },
  reducers: {
    increment: (state) => {
      state.value += 1  // Immer handles immutability
    }
  }
})

That's it. RTK generates action creators, action types, and sets up immutable updates with Immer. You write code that looks like mutation but actually returns new state.

Immer Logo

Redux Toolkit Modern Logo

RTK Query vs React Query: The Eternal Debate

RTK Query is Redux's answer to React Query. If you're already using Redux, RTK Query integrates better with your existing state. If you're starting fresh, React Query is simpler and has a bigger ecosystem.

RTK Query caches everything by default, sometimes too aggressively. React Query gives you more control over caching behavior but requires more setup.

TypeScript: Finally Fixed

Redux Toolkit 2.0 finally has decent TypeScript support. Before this, typing Redux properly required a PhD in TypeScript generics. RTK 2.0 includes pre-typed hooks that just work.

Old way: Define 47 types manually and pray you got the generics right.
New way: Use the pre-typed hooks and move on with your life.

Migration: It's Actually Doable

You can migrate from old Redux to RTK incrementally. Replace `createStore` with `configureStore` first (literally just swap the function call), then convert reducers to slices one at a time.

The migration guide is actually helpful, unlike most migration docs that assume you can rewrite your entire app over a weekend. Real migration timeline: 2-3 weeks for a medium app if you're disciplined about it, 6 months if you only touch it during sprints. Pro tip from experience: start with configureStore - it's backwards compatible so nothing breaks while you convert slice by slice. I learned this the hard way after breaking our entire checkout flow trying to convert everything at once.

Performance: RTK Fixes the Common Fuckups

RTK includes performance optimizations by default. The `autoBatchEnhancer` batches multiple state updates automatically, so rapid-fire actions don't cause 47 re-renders.

Most Redux performance issues come from bad selectors anyway. I've seen apps crawl to death because someone wrote useSelector(state => state) in a component that rendered 1000 times. Use `useSelector` with specific selectors, not (state) => state.everything. Trust me, debugging why your app suddenly takes 5 seconds to scroll is not fun.

React Redux Full Course for Beginners | Redux Toolkit Complete Tutorial by Dave Gray

This Redux Toolkit tutorial actually shows you how to build something real instead of the usual todo app bullshit. What you'll learn:- How to set up RTK without losing your mind- Why createSlice is magic compared to old Redux- How to handle async operations without Redux Saga- When to use selectors (and when not to)- Debugging with Redux DevTools (the best part)Watch: React Redux Full Course for BeginnersThis 2-hour course covers Redux Toolkit from scratch. The instructor actually builds a real app instead of explaining concepts in a vacuum. Skip to 45 minutes if you already know React basics, or 1:20 if you want to see the async stuff that always breaks in production.Why this doesn't waste your time:- Shows RTK patterns, not ancient Redux boilerplate from 2018- Includes real debugging scenarios with DevTools (actually useful)- Covers async data fetching with createAsyncThunk - watch this part twice, async always fucks people up- Explains when you actually need Redux vs overkill scenarios (spoiler: most apps don't need it)- Shows common mistakes and how to fix them - like forgetting to export your reducer and wondering why nothing works

📺 YouTube

Questions You'll Actually Ask (And Honest Answers)

Q

Is Redux overkill for my todo app?

A

Yes, absolutely. For 80% of apps, Redux is massive overkill. Use Context for auth/theme, useState for everything else. But when your state gets complex enough that you're debugging "why did updating user profile clear the shopping cart", you'll wish you had Redux.

Q

Learning curve - how fucked am I?

A

Expect to hate Redux for the first week, then never want to use anything else. The concepts are simple (action → reducer → new state), but thinking in Redux patterns takes time. You'll spend at least one weekend debugging why your action isn't reaching the reducer (spoiler: you forgot to add it to the store). RTK makes it way less painful than the old days, but you'll still curse at your screen a few times.

Q

Should I learn vanilla Redux first?

A

Fuck no. Start with Redux Toolkit. Learning vanilla Redux is like learning to drive on a manual transmission when you just want to get to work. RTK is the automatic transmission version.

Q

Redux vs Zustand - which one?

A

Redux RTK: Use when you need debugging superpowers for complex state interactions. The DevTools time-travel debugging will save your ass when tracking down race conditions.

Zustand: Use for simpler apps where state logic is straightforward. Less ceremony, less debugging power.

Q

Performance compared to Context API?

A

Context re-renders every consuming component when state changes. Redux only re-renders components whose selected state actually changed. Context is fine for auth/theme stuff, terrible for frequently updating data.

Q

RTK Query vs React Query vs SWR?

A

RTK Query: If you're already using Redux and want everything integrated. Caches aggressively, sometimes too much.

React Query: Bigger ecosystem, more mature, simpler if you're not using Redux. Most popular for good reason.

SWR: Similar to React Query, smaller bundle. Pick based on team preference.

Q

Can I migrate my existing Redux app to RTK?

A

Yes, and you should. Replace createStore with configureStore first (literally just swap the function call). Then convert reducers to slices gradually. The migration guide doesn't suck.

Q

TypeScript support - is it still a nightmare?

A

RTK 2.0 finally fixed TypeScript. Use the pre-typed hooks and stop fighting with generics. Old Redux TypeScript was a hellscape, new RTK TypeScript just works.

Q

When does Redux break down?

A

When your team doesn't understand selectors and writes useSelector(state => state) everywhere. Redux performance issues are usually selector issues. I once debugged an app that was re-rendering 50 components on every keystroke because someone grabbed the entire state tree in a header component. Use specific selectors, not grabbing the entire state tree. Also, if you're still using connect() instead of hooks in 2025, please stop.

Q

Do I need middleware for everything?

A

RTK includes Redux Thunk by default, which handles 90% of async use cases. Don't add Redux Saga unless you need complex async orchestration. Most apps don't.

Q

Redux with Next.js SSR?

A

Works fine but requires hydration setup.

Use redux-persist carefully with SSR

  • client state might not match server state, and you'll get that lovely "Hydration failed" error that takes 3 hours to debug. The Next.js example shows the right pattern.

Pro tip: wrap your store provider checks in typeof window !== 'undefined' or you'll hate your life.

Redux Resources That Don't Waste Your Time

Related Tools & Recommendations

pricing
Recommended

Should You Use TypeScript? Here's What It Actually Costs

TypeScript devs cost 30% more, builds take forever, and your junior devs will hate you for 3 months. But here's exactly when the math works in your favor.

TypeScript
/pricing/typescript-vs-javascript-development-costs/development-cost-analysis
100%
tool
Recommended

Recoil - Facebook's State Management Experiment That Got Shelved

Facebook built something clever, then abandoned it like they do with half their developer tools

Recoil
/tool/recoil/overview
66%
alternatives
Recommended

Fast React Alternatives That Don't Suck

integrates with React

React
/alternatives/react/performance-critical-alternatives
66%
integration
Recommended

Stripe Terminal React Native Production Integration Guide

Don't Let Beta Software Ruin Your Weekend: A Reality Check for Card Reader Integration

Stripe Terminal
/integration/stripe-terminal-react-native/production-deployment-guide
66%
howto
Recommended

Converting Angular to React: What Actually Happens When You Migrate

Based on 3 failed attempts and 1 that worked

Angular
/howto/convert-angular-app-react/complete-migration-guide
66%
tool
Recommended

TypeScript - JavaScript That Catches Your Bugs

Microsoft's type system that catches bugs before they hit production

TypeScript
/tool/typescript/overview
66%
tool
Recommended

JavaScript to TypeScript Migration - Practical Troubleshooting Guide

This guide covers the shit that actually breaks during migration

TypeScript
/tool/typescript/migration-troubleshooting-guide
66%
integration
Recommended

Stop Stripe from Destroying Your Serverless Performance

Cold starts are killing your payments, webhooks are timing out randomly, and your users think your checkout is broken. Here's how to fix the mess.

Stripe
/integration/stripe-nextjs-app-router/serverless-performance-optimization
60%
integration
Recommended

Supabase + Next.js + Stripe: How to Actually Make This Work

The least broken way to handle auth and payments (until it isn't)

Supabase
/integration/supabase-nextjs-stripe-authentication/customer-auth-payment-flow
60%
integration
Recommended

Claude API + Next.js App Router: What Actually Works in Production

I've been fighting with Claude API and Next.js App Router for 8 months. Here's what actually works, what breaks spectacularly, and how to avoid the gotchas that

Claude API
/integration/claude-api-nextjs-app-router/app-router-integration
60%
tool
Popular choice

MariaDB - What MySQL Should Have Been

Discover MariaDB, the powerful open-source alternative to MySQL. Learn why it was created, how to install it, and compare its benefits for your applications.

MariaDB
/tool/mariadb/overview
60%
alternatives
Popular choice

Docker Desktop Got Expensive - Here's What Actually Works

I've been through this migration hell multiple times because spending thousands annually on container tools is fucking insane

Docker Desktop
/alternatives/docker-desktop/migration-ready-alternatives
57%
tool
Popular choice

Protocol Buffers - Google's Binary Format That Actually Works

Explore Protocol Buffers, Google's efficient binary format. Learn why it's a faster, smaller alternative to JSON, how to set it up, and its benefits for inter-s

Protocol Buffers
/tool/protocol-buffers/overview
52%
news
Popular choice

Tesla FSD Still Can't Handle Edge Cases (Like Train Crossings)

Another reminder that "Full Self-Driving" isn't actually full self-driving

OpenAI GPT-5-Codex
/news/2025-09-16/tesla-fsd-train-crossing
50%
tool
Popular choice

Datadog - Expensive Monitoring That Actually Works

Finally, one dashboard instead of juggling 5 different monitoring tools when everything's on fire

Datadog
/tool/datadog/overview
47%
compare
Recommended

Python vs JavaScript vs Go vs Rust - Production Reality Check

What Actually Happens When You Ship Code With These Languages

javascript
/compare/python-javascript-go-rust/production-reality-check
45%
news
Recommended

JavaScript Gets Built-In Iterator Operators in ECMAScript 2025

Finally: Built-in functional programming that should have existed in 2015

OpenAI/ChatGPT
/news/2025-09-06/javascript-iterator-operators-ecmascript
45%
tool
Popular choice

Stop Writing Selenium Scripts That Break Every Week - Claude Can Click Stuff for You

Anthropic Computer Use API: When It Works, It's Magic. When It Doesn't, Budget $300+ Monthly.

Anthropic Computer Use API
/tool/anthropic-computer-use/api-integration-guide
45%
tool
Popular choice

Hugging Face Transformers - The ML Library That Actually Works

One library, 300+ model architectures, zero dependency hell. Works with PyTorch, TensorFlow, and JAX without making you reinstall your entire dev environment.

Hugging Face Transformers
/tool/huggingface-transformers/overview
42%
tool
Popular choice

Base - The Layer 2 That Actually Works

Explore Base, Coinbase's Layer 2 solution for Ethereum, known for its reliable performance and excellent developer experience. Learn how to build on Base and un

Baserow
/tool/base/overview
40%

Recommendations combine user behavior, content similarity, research intelligence, and SEO optimization