Look, I tried building auth myself. Twice. First time took three weeks and still had security holes you could drive a truck through. Second time I used NextAuth and spent more time fighting with session management than building features.
Then I discovered this combination: Clerk for the auth headache, Supabase for the database (with Row-Level Security that actually works), and Next.js 15 to tie it all together. It's not perfect, but it's the least painful way I've found to get production-ready authentication.
The Real Problem with Auth
Here's the thing nobody tells you: authentication isn't just "check if user is logged in." You need:
- Sign up/sign in flows that don't suck
- Password reset that actually works
- Social login (because users expect it)
- Session management that handles edge cases
- Database security so users can't see each other's data
- Token refresh that doesn't break your app
Building this yourself means months of work and constant security patches. The OWASP Auth Cheat Sheet lists 50+ security considerations you need to handle. Using separate services means integration hell, but at least you're not implementing OAuth from scratch and dealing with PKCE flows.
How The Pieces Actually Work Together
Here's what happens when a user signs in (and where it breaks):
- Clerk handles the auth dance - User clicks sign in, Clerk shows the modal, handles OAuth with Google/GitHub, validates everything
- JWT tokens get passed around - Clerk issues a JWT token with the user ID in the
sub
claim - Supabase verifies the token - Using Clerk's JWKS endpoint and JWT verification (this took me forever to configure right)
- Row-Level Security kicks in - Supabase automatically filters queries based on `requesting_user_id()` function and PostgreSQL RLS policies
- Next.js does the plumbing - Server Components get auth state, Client Components get real-time data via Supabase Realtime
The part that'll bite you: token refresh happens silently, but if your Supabase client isn't configured right, you'll get random 401s that are hell to debug.
Why I Actually Use This Stack
Clerk's UI components don't suck: Their sign-in modal looks professional out of the box. Compare that to building your own forms with form validation, error handling, and accessibility compliance - you'll spend weeks getting it right.
Supabase RLS is bulletproof: Once you set up Row-Level Security policies correctly using PostgreSQL's native RLS, users literally cannot access each other's data. Even if they figure out your API endpoints and try direct database queries.
Next.js 15 App Router plays nice: The App Router architecture with Server Actions and Middleware handles auth state cleanly. No more wrestling with cookies or session storage.
It scales without thinking: I've deployed this pattern on apps with 50K+ users - Clerk handles the auth load, Supabase handles the database queries, Vercel handles the Next.js hosting.
The pain points: Clerk gets expensive fast ($25 base + $0.02 per MAU after 10k), Supabase's free tier is generous but you'll hit database limits if you're not careful, and debugging JWT issues means understanding three different systems when shit breaks.
Worth it? Hell yes. This integration saved me probably 6 weeks of building auth from scratch, and I haven't had a single security incident in production since implementing it.