Reality Check - What Actually Matters

Feature

Replit

Cursor

GitHub Codespaces

What it's actually good for

Quick demos and learning

AI-powered local dev

Enterprise teams with GitHub obsession

Setup reality

Browser, done

Install once

Wait for the damn VM

AI that doesn't suck

Replit Agent (decent)

Best AI completion I've used

Copilot (separate $10/month)

Real cost

$20/month if you use AI features

$20/month, worth it

$0.18/hour (adds up fast)

Collaboration reality

Actually works in real-time

VS Code Live Share when it works

GitHub integration, obviously

Speed when it matters

Slower than localhost

Local = fast

Depends on VM size you pay for

When your internet dies

You're fucked

Keep working

You're fucked

The catch

Randomly resets sometimes

Battery drain from AI

Expensive for heavy usage

I've tried all three. Each one sucks at different things.

Docker on my old MacBook was making the fan sound like a leaf blower. Multiple containers? Forget it. So I tried these cloud dev platforms. They all work, sort of, but they're completely different approaches to the same problem.

Replit: When You Just Want to Code Something

Replit Interface

I discovered Replit while trying to quickly prototype a REST API during a client meeting. Opening a browser tab and having a working Python environment in 2 seconds felt like magic. No Docker setup, no virtual environments, no "it works on my machine" bullshit.

What actually works:

  • Instant everything - click a template, start coding
  • Sharing a live coding session just works (shared the link, client could see my code in real-time)
  • Deployment is stupidly simple - hit deploy, get a URL
  • The Replit Database is just a key-value store, but it's there when you need it
  • Real-time collaboration beats any other platform I've tried - just share a link and multiple people can edit simultaneously
  • Ghost Writer AI is actually decent for simple tasks - generates boilerplate code and explains complex functions
  • Built-in package management handles dependencies automatically
  • Version history saved my ass multiple times
  • Always-on hosting keeps your apps running 24/7

The stuff that'll drive you crazy:

  • My environment reset twice and took my changes with it. No warning, just back to the last save.
  • Performance is fine for web stuff, terrible for anything heavy. Tried processing some images and it just gave up after 30 seconds
  • AI credits vanish fast. Spent like $25 in three days just building a React app
  • Still charges you $20/month even if you don't use it. Paid for two months while traveling and barely touched it
  • Free tier maxes out at 0.5 vCPU and 512MB RAM - basically unusable for anything real
  • Storage caps at 10GB unless you pay more. Hit it immediately with node_modules and some Docker stuff
  • No internet = no work. Tried coding on a plane once. Big mistake
  • Python environments randomly break and you have to rebuild them. Happened twice last month

I use Replit for demos, quick prototypes, and when I need to collaborate with junior developers. It removes all the friction but don't expect it to replace your main dev environment.

Cursor: VS Code but the AI Actually Helps

Cursor Code Editor

After getting tired of GitHub Copilot suggesting console.log('hello world') for everything, I tried Cursor. It's basically VS Code with AI that doesn't completely suck.

Where it shines:

The reality check:

  • Battery dies fast and laptop runs hot as hell. Can't use it on my lap anymore when the AI is working hard
  • Twenty bucks a month is reasonable if you code every day. Waste of money if you don't
  • AI gets cocky and suggests solutions that look right but are completely wrong. Spent an hour debugging perfectly formatted garbage
  • Extension compatibility isn't perfect - some language servers conflict with Cursor's AI features
  • Heavy users hit limits fast. My coworker got a $40 overage bill after a weekend hackathon
  • Model switching UI is confusing. Took forever to figure out which one to use when
  • Big projects take like 30 minutes to index before AI works. Useless until then
  • Sometimes the AI just stops working and you have to restart the whole thing. No idea why

I switched to Cursor as my daily driver for new projects. The AI genuinely speeds up routine coding tasks, but you still need to know what you're doing.

GitHub Codespaces: For Teams That Live in GitHub

Codespaces made sense for my team because we were already using GitHub for everything. Having dev environments that spin up pre-configured with all our tools seemed ideal.

The good parts:

The reality:

  • Startup time kills your flow. Sixty seconds is forever when you're trying to fix something quick. I've lost count of how many times I started one then forgot what I was doing while waiting
  • The hourly pricing is sneaky. Left a 4-core instance running over a weekend and got a $30 surprise. Storage costs add up too with all those Docker layers
  • Connection drops happen at the worst times. VS Code just freezes mid-sentence and sometimes you lose stuff
  • Our bill exploded from $50 to like $250 a month once the whole team started using it. Everyone forgets to shut down their instances
  • If the container hangs, killing the terminal process usually fixes it. Learned this the hard way
  • Timeout settings suck. Either kills your session while you're thinking or wastes money when you walk away
  • Latency is annoying if you're not in the US. Our guy in India says there's like a 200ms delay on everything
  • The 2-core instances are too slow. 4-core works but costs add up. 8-core is fast but expensive as hell

We use Codespaces for complex feature work and pair programming, but most day-to-day coding happens locally because of the startup latency.

Detailed Feature Comparison Matrix

Category

Item

Replit

Cursor

GitHub Codespaces

Development Environment & Performance

Environment Type

Browser-based cloud IDE

Desktop application (VS Code fork)

Cloud-hosted VS Code

Development Environment & Performance

CPU Performance

Shared, sometimes slow

Your machine

2-4 cores usually

Development Environment & Performance

Memory

Not much

Whatever your laptop has

Pay for more RAM

Development Environment & Performance

Storage

10GB free, more costs extra

Local disk

Starts at 32GB

Development Environment & Performance

Network Dependency

Full internet required

Works offline, sync on reconnect

Internet required for remote access

Development Environment & Performance

Boot Time

Instant (<2 seconds)

Local launch (~5 seconds)

VM provisioning (30-60 seconds)

AI Features

  • What Actually Works

Code Completion

Hit or miss, better for simple stuff

Best I've used for complex completions

Standard Copilot, you know how it is

AI Features

  • What Actually Works

AI Models

GPT-4 and Claude (Replit Agent)

GPT-4, Claude 3.5 Sonnet, others

GitHub Copilot (OpenAI Codex)

AI Features

  • What Actually Works

Conversation Mode

Replit Agent can build whole features

Chat mode that actually understands your code

Copilot Chat (needs separate subscription)

AI Features

  • What Actually Works

Context Understanding

Knows about files in your repl

Understands entire project structure

Limited to current file mostly

AI Features

  • What Actually Works

Cost Reality

Burns through credits fast

$20/month gets you decent usage

Extra $10/month for Copilot

Collaboration and Team Features

Real-time Collaboration

Native multiplayer editing

VS Code Live Share compatible

Built-in sharing + Live Share

Collaboration and Team Features

Version Control

Git integration + visual interface

Native Git + GitHub integration

Deep GitHub integration

Collaboration and Team Features

Team Management

User roles, team billing

Admin dashboard, usage analytics

Organization-level controls

Collaboration and Team Features

Code Review

Comment system in editor

External tools required

Native GitHub PR integration

Collaboration and Team Features

Access Control

Private repls, team permissions

Privacy mode, SSO (Teams plan)

Repository-based permissions

Deployment and Production Integration

Built-in Hosting

Native deployment with custom domains

No (external deployment required)

GitHub Pages + Actions integration

Deployment and Production Integration

CI/CD Integration

Limited pipeline features

External CI/CD required

Full GitHub Actions integration

Deployment and Production Integration

Database Support

Replit Database (key-value)

External databases

Any cloud database

Deployment and Production Integration

Environment Variables

Secrets management built-in

Local + deployment-specific

GitHub Secrets integration

Deployment and Production Integration

Production Scaling

Replit hosting (limited scale)

Deploy to any cloud provider

Azure/AWS integration via Actions

Real Pricing (What You'll Actually Pay)

Free Tier

Public repls only

Limited AI requests

60-120 hours/month depending on GitHub plan

Real Pricing (What You'll Actually Pay)

Actually Useful

$20/month Core + AI credits

$20/month Pro

$0.18/hour (2-core) to $1.44/hour (32-core)

Real Pricing (What You'll Actually Pay)

Team Plans

$20/month per user

$40/month per user

Depends on usage

Real Pricing (What You'll Actually Pay)

The Fine Print

AI features cost extra

AI heavy usage costs extra

Storage costs extra ($0.07/GB/month)

Real Workflows - What Actually Happens

Cloud Development Workflow

Here's how these platforms work in practice, not in marketing brochures. I'll walk through the actual scenarios where I've used each one.

The "Oh Shit, I Need to Demo This in 10 Minutes" Scenario

The situation: Client call in 10 minutes, need to show a working API endpoint with some data.

Replit saved my ass: Opened a browser tab, clicked a Python Flask template, had a JSON API running with fake data in 3 minutes. Shared the live URL during the screen share. Client was impressed, I looked competent.

Why Cursor/Codespaces would've failed: Clone repo, set up virtual env, install dependencies, configure database... by the time I got it running, the call would be over.

The "Let's Pair Program on This Bug" Experience

The situation: Complex React state management bug that needed two brains.

GitHub Codespaces worked great: Shared a Codespace link, my colleague joined instantly. Same environment, same extensions, same debugger setup. Fixed the bug in 20 minutes because we could both see exactly the same thing.

Real gotchas I discovered:

The "I'm Refactoring This Legacy Nightmare" Project

The situation: 15,000-line React component that needed to be split up (don't ask me how it got that big).

Cursor was incredibly helpful: The AI could suggest reasonable ways to extract components while understanding the full context. It caught dependency issues I would've missed. Turned a 2-week refactor into 4 days.

What actually happened:

The "New Developer Onboarding" Nightmare

The situation: Junior dev joining the team, needs to get productive fast.

Codespaces eliminated the usual setup hell:

The old way (before Codespaces): 2-3 days of Slack messages like "npm install failed", "Docker won't start", "which Python version?", "why is my port 3000 taken?"

The "Working from a Coffee Shop" Reality Check

Internet situation: Spotty WiFi, frequent disconnections.

Cursor wins by default: Everything runs locally. Connection dies? Keep working. Reconnect later and push changes.

Replit/Codespaces: Every disconnect interrupts your flow. Auto-save helps but you're basically fucked without internet connectivity.

Real experience: Tried to work on a Codespace from a train. Spent more time reconnecting than coding. Network debugging became a daily ritual.

The "Building a Side Project" Long Game

The situation: Personal project I work on sporadically, maybe 2-3 hours per week.

Cursor for day-to-day development: Fast startup, works offline, AI helps with boilerplate.

Replit for quick experiments: Testing new libraries or frameworks. Fork a template, try something, delete it if it sucks.

Codespaces for deployment: Connected to GitHub Actions, automatically deploys when I push to main.

The Battery Life Reality

Working remotely all day on battery:

  • Cursor: Laptop gets hot, battery lasts maybe 4 hours with heavy AI usage
  • Replit/Codespaces: Browser-based, better battery life but you're fucked without internet

Solution I ended up with: Cursor for focused coding sessions when plugged in, Replit for quick tasks and demos when on battery.

The "Something Broke in Production" Emergency

Production Emergency

The situation: Bug in prod, need to fix it fast.

GitHub Codespaces to the rescue: Spun up environment in 30 seconds, same as prod config. Found the issue, pushed fix, closed laptop. No context switching from local environment to production setup.

Why this mattered: The production bug was related to a specific Node.js version. My local machine had a different version. Codespaces matched production exactly.

My Actual Recommendation After 8 Months

The reality is that each platform excels at different types of work, and the best approach is using the right tool for each situation instead of trying to force one platform to do everything.

What I actually use now:

  • Cursor for 80% of my daily development work - the AI is genuinely helpful and it's fast
  • Replit for quick demos, teaching, and testing new frameworks
  • Codespaces when working with my team on complex features or when I need exact production parity

Bottom line: You'll probably end up with accounts on all three like I did. Start with whichever solves your biggest current pain point, then expand from there.

The Questions Everyone Actually Asks

Q

Which one should I use if I'm just starting out?

A

Replit. Click, code. No installation nightmare, no "works on my machine" bullshit. Perfect for beginners who just want to learn without spending a week on setup.The real win is that you can share your work instantly. Stuck on something? Send a link to someone who can help. Want to show off what you built? Copy-paste a URL.

Q

Will my VS Code extensions work?

A

Cursor: Yes, it's literally VS Code with AI bolted on. All your extensions, themes, and keybindings just work. Codespaces: Most extensions work, but some that need local system access don't. I've had issues with Docker extensions and some debuggers. Replit: Nope. They have their own thing going. It's decent but if you're attached to specific extensions, you'll be disappointed.

Q

What happens if I stop paying?

A

Replit: Your private stuff becomes read-only. Public repls stay forever. Cursor: Code stays on your machine, AI features stop working. Basically turns back into regular VS Code. Codespaces: They delete your environments after 30 days, but your code is still in GitHub. Just don't leave important stuff only in the Codespace.

Q

Which AI actually helps instead of just getting in the way?

A

Cursor's AI actually helps. Gets it right most of the time, unlike Copilot suggesting hello world for everything. Replit Agent is good for building simple stuff from scratch. It can create a working web app from a description, which is pretty cool for prototypes. GitHub Copilot (in Codespaces) is... GitHub Copilot. You know what you're getting. Sometimes helpful, sometimes suggests console.log('TODO') for everything.

Q

Does it actually scale for real teams?

A

Codespaces wins for teams over 5 people. Environment consistency is huge

  • no more "works on my machine" problems. Onboarding new developers takes minutes instead of days. Cursor Teams is fine for smaller teams but lacks enterprise stuff like SSO and proper admin controls. Replit Teams works for classrooms and small teams but I wouldn't trust it with anything important at scale.
Q

Can I work without internet?

A

Only Cursor. Everything else requires internet. I learned this the hard way trying to code on a plane with Replit. Spent 6 hours staring at a loading screen.

Q

Which one deploys easiest?

A

Replit is stupid simple. Hit the deploy button, get a URL. Perfect for demos and small projects. Codespaces + GitHub Actions is powerful but complex. Great for real projects with proper CI/CD. Cursor doesn't deploy anything. It's just a code editor. You need to set up deployment elsewhere.

Q

What's the performance actually like?

A

Cursor is fastest because it's running on your machine. No network latency, no shared resources. Codespaces depends on what VM you pay for. The 2-core option feels sluggish, 4-core is decent, 8-core+ is fast but expensive. Replit is fine for web development but don't try to run anything CPU-intensive. I tried to train a small ML model once and it timed out after 10 minutes.

Q

What will this actually cost me?

A

Light usage: All have decent free tiers. Daily development:

  • Cursor: $20/month, predictable
  • Replit: $20/month base + AI credits (can get expensive)
  • Codespaces: $30-50/month if you're not careful about leaving environments running

Pro tip: Codespaces will surprise you with costs. Set up billing alerts or you'll get a $200 bill like we did.

Q

How do I get my code out if I want to switch?

A

From Replit: Git push to GitHub or download as zip. Pretty straightforward. From Cursor: It's all local anyway. Just push to whatever git remote you want. From Codespaces: Your code should be in GitHub already. The environment config might need to be recreated elsewhere.

Q

Where do I go when stuff breaks?

A

Replit: Discord community is pretty active. Official support is okay. Codespaces: GitHub support if you're paying, otherwise Stack Overflow. Cursor: Growing Discord community, but it's still smaller. Forum has helpful people.

Q

Should I worry about security?

A

Codespaces is most secure

  • SOC2 compliant, enterprise-grade stuff. Good for corporate environments. Cursor has privacy mode to keep your code from training their AI models. Turn this on if you're working on proprietary stuff. Replit processes your code for AI features unless you opt out. Fine for personal projects, maybe not for client work.
Q

Can I build mobile apps?

A

Replit: Great for React Native web previews, but you can't test on actual devices. Cursor: Full access to iOS/Android simulators and devices since it's running locally. Codespaces: Decent for cross-platform frameworks like React Native, but device testing is tricky.

Actually Useful Resources

Related Tools & Recommendations

compare
Similar content

Best AI Coding Tools: Copilot, Cursor, Claude Code Compared

Cursor vs GitHub Copilot vs Claude Code vs Windsurf: Real Talk From Someone Who's Used Them All

Cursor
/compare/cursor/claude-code/ai-coding-assistants/ai-coding-assistants-comparison
100%
review
Similar content

GitHub Copilot vs Cursor: 2025 AI Coding Assistant Review

I've been coding with both for 3 months. Here's which one actually helps vs just getting in the way.

GitHub Copilot
/review/github-copilot-vs-cursor/comprehensive-evaluation
96%
review
Similar content

Windsurf vs Cursor: Best AI Code Editor for Developers in 2025

Cursor vs Windsurf: I spent 6 months and $400 testing both - here's which one doesn't suck

Windsurf
/review/windsurf-vs-cursor/comprehensive-review
91%
compare
Similar content

Cursor vs Copilot vs Codeium: Enterprise AI Adoption Reality Check

I've Watched Dozens of Enterprise AI Tool Rollouts Crash and Burn. Here's What Actually Works.

Cursor
/compare/cursor/copilot/codeium/windsurf/amazon-q/claude/enterprise-adoption-analysis
89%
compare
Similar content

Cursor vs Copilot vs Codeium: Choosing Your AI Coding Assistant

After two years using these daily, here's what actually matters for choosing an AI coding tool

Cursor
/compare/cursor/github-copilot/codeium/tabnine/amazon-q-developer/windsurf/market-consolidation-upheaval
87%
compare
Similar content

AI Coding Assistants: Cursor, Copilot, Windsurf, Codeium, Amazon Q

After GitHub Copilot suggested componentDidMount for the hundredth time in a hooks-only React codebase, I figured I should test the alternatives

Cursor
/compare/cursor/github-copilot/windsurf/codeium/amazon-q-developer/comprehensive-developer-comparison
82%
compare
Similar content

AI Coding Tools: Cursor, Copilot, Codeium, Tabnine, Amazon Q Review

Every company just screwed their users with price hikes. Here's which ones are still worth using.

Cursor
/compare/cursor/github-copilot/codeium/tabnine/amazon-q-developer/comprehensive-ai-coding-comparison
80%
compare
Similar content

Enterprise Editor Deployment: Zed vs VS Code vs Cursor Review

Zed vs VS Code vs Cursor: Why Your Next Editor Rollout Will Be a Disaster

Zed
/compare/zed/visual-studio-code/cursor/enterprise-deployment-showdown
80%
compare
Similar content

Windsurf vs Cursor: Enterprise AI Editor Deployment Guide

I've deployed both. Here's which one won't make you hate your life.

Windsurf
/compare/windsurf/cursor/enterprise-deployment/enterprise-deployment-readiness
78%
tool
Similar content

GitHub Codespaces - Cloud Dev Environments That Actually Work

Discover GitHub Codespaces: cloud-based VS Code dev environments with instant project setup. Understand its core features, benefits, and a realistic look at pri

GitHub Codespaces
/tool/github-codespaces/overview
74%
tool
Similar content

Cursor AI: VS Code with Smart AI for Developers

It's basically VS Code with actually smart AI baked in. Works pretty well if you write code for a living.

Cursor
/tool/cursor/overview
71%
review
Similar content

Zed vs VS Code vs Cursor: Performance Benchmark & 30-Day Review

30 Days of Actually Using These Things - Here's What Actually Matters

Zed
/review/zed-vs-vscode-vs-cursor/performance-benchmark-review
71%
compare
Similar content

Augment Code vs Claude vs Cursor vs Windsurf: AI Tools Compared

Tried all four AI coding tools. Here's what actually happened.

/compare/augment-code/claude-code/cursor/windsurf/enterprise-ai-coding-reality-check
69%
compare
Similar content

AI Coding Assistants 2025 Pricing Breakdown & Real Cost Analysis

GitHub Copilot vs Cursor vs Claude Code vs Tabnine vs Amazon Q Developer: The Real Cost Analysis

GitHub Copilot
/compare/github-copilot/cursor/claude-code/tabnine/amazon-q-developer/ai-coding-assistants-2025-pricing-breakdown
67%
alternatives
Similar content

GitHub Copilot Alternatives: Ditch Microsoft & Find Better AI Tools

Copilot's gotten expensive as hell and slow as shit. Here's what actually works better.

GitHub Copilot
/alternatives/github-copilot/enterprise-migration
56%
review
Similar content

AI Coding Assistants 2025: Comprehensive Evaluation & Comparison

Real testing results from 6 months of using GitHub Copilot, Cursor, Claude Code, and the rest

/review/ai-coding-assistants-2025/comprehensive-evaluation
56%
tool
Similar content

GitHub Codespaces Troubleshooting: Fix Common Issues & Errors

Troubleshoot common GitHub Codespaces issues like 'no space left on device', slow performance, and creation failures. Learn how to fix errors and optimize your

GitHub Codespaces
/tool/github-codespaces/troubleshooting-gotchas
54%
tool
Similar content

GitHub Codespaces Enterprise: Cost Optimization & Management Guide

Master GitHub Codespaces enterprise deployment. Learn strategies to optimize costs, manage usage, and prevent budget overruns for your engineering organization

GitHub Codespaces
/tool/github-codespaces/enterprise-deployment-cost-optimization
49%
tool
Similar content

Amazon Q Developer Review: Is it Worth $19/Month vs. Copilot?

Amazon's coding assistant that works great for AWS stuff, sucks at everything else, and costs way more than Copilot. If you live in AWS hell, it might be worth

Amazon Q Developer
/tool/amazon-q-developer/overview
49%
compare
Similar content

TurboTax Crypto vs CoinTracker vs Koinly: Crypto Tax Software Guide

Crypto tax software: They all suck in different ways - here's how to pick the least painful option

TurboTax Crypto
/compare/turbotax/cointracker/koinly/decision-framework
47%

Recommendations combine user behavior, content similarity, research intelligence, and SEO optimization