The Reality of Using Nix

I've been using Nix for 3 years now. First month was hell, now I can't go back to npm breaking my environment every week.

Nix is a functional package manager that stores everything in /nix/store with weird hash names like /nix/store/b6gvzjyb2pg0kjfwrjmg1vfhh54ad73z-firefox-33.1/. First time you see this, you think it's broken. It's not. This is how Nix prevents the "install something, break everything else" problem that plagues traditional package managers.

Nix Architecture Overview

What Actually Makes It Different

Traditional imperative package managers are stateful - they run install scripts that modify your system state. Nix is functional - packages are immutable values that can't interfere with each other. Sounds academic, but it means you can:

We're on version 2.29 now (September 2025). NixOS 25.05 "Warbler" dropped in May and actually works great. The community actually gives a shit and keeps things moving.

NixOS Community Growth

Learning Curve Reality Check

Expect to be confused for 2-3 weeks. The Nix language is functional programming on hard mode, and the error messages are cryptic garbage that make you question your sanity. Documentation ranges from excellent to "figure it out yourself," usually when you need it most.

But once it finally clicks (and trust me, it will), you realize every other package manager is fundamentally broken and you can't go back. I now use Nix for:

Real-World Gotchas

Companies like FlightAware, Shopify, and Tweag use Nix because it prevents "works on dev, crashes in prod" disasters. The isolation guarantees are worth the learning curve.

Package Manager Comparison

What You Care About

Nix

Homebrew

APT

Docker

Actually Works

Yes, after you suffer through learning it

LOL no, breaks every OS update

Until you need any version that isn't ancient

If you enjoy watching paint dry

Learning Time

2-3 weeks of pure confusion

5 minutes, then lifetime of frustration

You think you know it (you don't)

Weekend to think you're good

When It Breaks

Rare, rollback in 5 seconds

Every few months, nuke everything

Pray to the dependency gods

Delete everything, start over

Disk Space

Eats disk like it's free

Reasonable until it isn't

Minimal and broken

Also eats disk, slower

Multiple Versions

Just fucking works

Absolutely not happening

Good luck with that

Build 47 different containers

How Nix Actually Works (And Why It's Different)

Nix Store Structure

The Weird Store Directory That Makes Everything Work

Everything lives in /nix/store with paths like /nix/store/b6gvzjyb2pg0-firefox-120.0/. That hash isn't random - it's computed from:

Change anything - even a fucking comment in a dependency's source - and you get a completely different hash. Sounds insane, right? But this is exactly how Nix prevents "works on my machine" disasters.

I learned this the hard way when a one-line config change triggered rebuilding half my system from source. Took 4 hours. But that rebuild was identical to what anyone else would get with the same config.

Multi-User Setup (Less Pain Than Expected)

The daemon setup actually works well. Non-root users can install packages safely because builds run in isolated namespaces.

Your packages don't interfere with other users, but everyone shares the same store. So if your teammate already built something, you get it for free.

One gotcha: the build users (nixbld1, nixbld2, etc.) might confuse your monitoring tools.

The Functional Language (Prepare for Pain)

The Nix language looks simple but will fuck with your head if you're used to imperative languages:

## This looks innocent
firefox = callPackage ./firefox.nix { };

## Custom variant - this is where it gets weird
firefoxDev = firefox.override { 
  enableDebug = true;
  enableTests = true;
};

Everything is lazy-evaluated. Functions are pure (no side effects). The type system is... unique. Expect to spend a weekend just understanding how to read package definitions.

But the composability is powerful. You can create variants of packages without touching the original definitions.

Garbage Collection (Because Disk Space Isn't Free)

Nix eats disk space like crazy. After a few months, you'll have 50GB in /nix/store. Run `nix-collect-garbage -d` to clean up old generations.

Pro tip: `nix-collect-garbage --delete-older-than 30d` keeps recent stuff but nukes old builds. I run this weekly.

The garbage collector is smart - it only removes packages not referenced by any profile or running process. You literally can't break your system by running garbage collection, which is more than I can say for apt autoremove.

Nix Development Environments

Development Environments That Actually Work

This is where Nix shines:

## Instant environment with specific versions
nix-shell -p nodejs-18_x python311 postgresql

## Project-specific environment
nix-shell  # reads shell.nix

The environment is perfectly isolated. Want Node 16 for one project and Node 18 for another? Just works. No more "hold on, let me reinstall Node and break three other projects" bullshit.

Flakes are even better but they're "experimental" (everyone uses them anyway):

{
  description = "Dev environment";
  inputs.nixpkgs.url = "github:NixOS/nixpkgs/nixos-unstable";
  
  outputs = { nixpkgs, ... }: {
    devShells.x86_64-linux.default = 
      with nixpkgs.legacyPackages.x86_64-linux;
      mkShell {
        buildInputs = [ nodejs python3 postgresql ];
      };
  };
}

Add `direnv` and your environment activates automatically when you cd into the project.

Binary Cache (Why Nix Doesn't Always Build From Source)

The binary cache serves pre-built packages. Most of the time, you download binaries instead of compiling.

When it works, installs are fast. When it doesn't, enjoy building Firefox from source for 3 hours.

Cache hit rate is usually good for common packages. For weird custom stuff or if you modify anything, you're building from source.

Organizations run private caches for proprietary packages. Works well once you get the signing keys sorted out.

Questions Everyone Actually Asks

Q

Is this ready for production or will it break everything?

A

I've been running it in prod for 2 years. Works great. Your ops team will hate you during the migration though. Companies like FlightAware use it because "works on my machine, crashes in prod" isn't acceptable anymore. The reproducible builds actually prevent disasters.

Q

How much disk space will this eat?

A

A lot. Plan on 30-50% more disk usage because nothing is shared. My dev machine has 40GB in /nix/store and I'm not even heavy user.The garbage collector helps, but you'll still use more disk than apt/homebrew. SSDs are cheap, broken deployments aren't.

Q

Can I use this with Homebrew/apt without breaking everything?

A

Yeah, Nix isolates itself completely. I run it alongside Homebrew on macOS. No conflicts because Nix doesn't touch system directories.Fair warning: once you get used to Nix, you'll get frustrated when Homebrew breaks on macOS updates.

Q

What's the difference between Nix, NixOS, and Nixpkgs?

A
  • Nix: The package manager. Install on any Linux/macOS
  • NixOS: Linux distro where everything is managed by Nix
  • Nixpkgs: The giant repo of package definitions

Start with just Nix. NixOS is all-in commitment.

Q

How bad is the learning curve?

A

Brutal. Expect 2-3 weeks of "what the fuck is happening." The Nix language is functional programming on hard mode.But once it clicks, you realize imperative package managers are fundamentally broken. I can't go back to npm/pip destroying my environment every week.

Q

Should I use Flakes?

A

They're "experimental" but everyone uses them anyway. The Nix community moves faster than official docs. Flakes solve real problems the old way didn't.Expect some rough edges and occasional breaking changes. Still worth it.

Q

How do I install proprietary crap that expects normal Linux?

A
  • Steam: Just works on NixOS
  • Random binary: Wrap it with buildFHSUserEnv
  • Enterprise garbage: Pain in the ass, but doable

Some stuff fights Nix's isolation model. You'll spend time fixing it.

Q

What happens when the binary cache breaks?

A

Everything builds from source. Hope you have time to kill.First time this happens, you think Nix is broken. It's not

  • it's building your packages from scratch. Takes hours but works.
Q

Does this make sense for simple Docker images?

A

Yes. dockerTools.buildImage creates tiny images with only what you need. No Ubuntu base image bloat.But learning Nix just for Docker might be overkill unless you're already using it.

Q

How are security updates handled?

A

Package updates in Nixpkgs, then you rebuild. Simple. The atomic updates mean you don't end up with half-patched systems.Response time is usually good, but you're dependent on someone updating the package.

Q

Should beginners use this?

A

If you're willing to be confused for a few weeks, yes. The reproducible environments actually make complex setups easier once you understand them.If you just want to npm install and move on with life, no.

Q

Nix vs Guix - what's the difference?

A

Guix uses Scheme instead of the Nix language. More GNU philosophy, smaller ecosystem. Nix has more packages and works on macOS. Unless you love Scheme or hate non-GPL software, stick with Nix.

Where to Go When You're Stuck