Why You Actually Need a Go Proxy (And How to Stop Hating Dependencies)

Go Gopher Mascot

Athens Go Proxy Architecture

If you've ever sat through a demo where go get decided to time out at the worst possible moment, you understand why Go proxies exist. Before Go 1.13, dependency management was basically Russian roulette. Half the time it worked, the other half you'd get "connection timeout" or "repository not found" because someone moved their GitHub repo or you hit rate limits. Fun times.

Then proxy.golang.org became the default and suddenly builds stopped breaking every time someone deleted a tag. Here's what actually happens now:

  1. You run go get github.com/some/module@v1.2.3
  2. Go checks the proxy first (usually proxy.golang.org)
  3. If it's cached there, you get it in under 100ms
  4. If not, the proxy fetches it from GitHub and caches it forever
  5. Everyone else gets the cached version instantly

The Real Benefits (not marketing BS)

  • No more vanishing dependencies: Once a version is in the proxy, it's permanent. Even if the author deletes their repo in a rage, your builds still work.
  • Faster builds: Local cache means no waiting for GitHub's servers to wake up
  • Corporate firewall friendly: Your company probably blocks direct Git access anyway
  • Checksum verification: The checksum database ensures nobody swapped malicious code into your dependencies

When Things Go Wrong (and they will)

I've seen proxy.golang.org return 410 Gone for retracted versions, which breaks builds until you figure out the version was pulled. The error message is cryptic: "module not found" when it really means "this version was marked as broken by the author."

Another fun one: private repos. If you don't set GOPRIVATE=github.com/yourcompany/*, Go tries to fetch your secret internal modules through the public proxy, which obviously fails. Took me 2 hours to figure that out the first time.

Athens vs Public Proxy

Athens is what you run when proxy.golang.org isn't enough. It's basically your own proxy that can handle private modules and cache everything locally. The documentation is actually decent, which is rare.

Grab Engineering has a good writeup about why they switched to Athens for their monorepo. TLDR: proxy.golang.org was too slow for their CI/CD pipeline.

Other companies like Xendit also document their proxy setups. The pattern is always the same: start with proxy.golang.org, realize it's not enough for enterprise needs, switch to Athens.

GitHub itself has issues with proxy timeouts, so you're not alone if builds randomly fail with "fetch timed out". The Go team acknowledges this is a problem but the solution is running your own proxy.

Configuration That Actually Works

Go Module Dependency Flow

export GOPROXY=https://proxy.golang.org,direct
export GOSUMDB=sum.golang.org
export GOPRIVATE=github.com/yourcompany/*

The direct fallback means if all proxies fail, Go downloads from Git directly. Without it, your build dies completely when proxies are down.

For debugging proxy issues, check the official Go modules wiki and Stack Overflow Go modules tag where people actually solve real problems, not the sanitized documentation.

Anyway, here's what people actually ask when their builds start failing.

Questions Developers Actually Ask (With Honest Answers)

Q

Why does `go get` fail with "410 Gone" during builds?

A

This usually means the module version was retracted by the author because it was buggy. The proxy returns HTTP 410 to tell you "this version exists but don't use it." Fix: upgrade to a non-retracted version or downgrade to the last good one.I spent 3 hours debugging this when a popular crypto library retracted a version that had a critical vulnerability.

Q

My private repos keep failing with "module not found"

A

You forgot to set GOPRIVATE. Without it, Go tries to fetch your secret company repos through the public proxy, which obviously can't access them.bashexport GOPRIVATE=github.com/yourcompany/*,gitlab.yourcompany.com/*This forces Go to bypass proxies for matching patterns and fetch directly from Git.Fun fact: this breaks if your username has a space in it on Windows. Good luck with that.

Q

Athens keeps running out of memory, what's wrong?

A

Athens defaults to unlimited memory caching, which sounds great until it devours your RAM. If you're caching large modules like Kubernetes libraries, configure disk storage instead:yamlstoragetype: diskdisk:rootPath: /var/lib/athens

Q

Proxy timeouts are killing our CI builds

A

Set shorter timeouts and better fallbacks:bashexport GOPROXY=https://your-athens.com,https://goproxy.io,proxy.golang.org,directexport GOTIMEOUT=30sMultiple proxies mean if one is slow, Go tries the next. direct is your nuclear option.

Q

Can I verify modules are coming from the right source?

A

Yes, through the checksum database. Go automatically verifies every download matches the expected hash. If someone compromises a proxy and serves malicious code, the checksum verification catches it.Disable only if you're running air-gapped systems: export GOSUMDB=off

Q

Why is my Athens proxy serving stale versions?

A

Athens caches forever by default. If you need to force refresh (maybe the upstream repo was fixed), restart Athens or clear its cache. There's no "refresh this module" API, which is annoying.

Q

Go 1.21+ broke our proxy setup, what changed?

A

Go 1.21 introduced automatic toolchain management which breaks if your proxy caches the wrong toolchain version. Athens 0.14.0+ fixed this, but older versions will randomly fail with "toolchain not available". Upgrade Athens or pin GOTOOLCHAIN=local.

Q

Should I use proxy.golang.org or run my own?

A

Go Module Version SelectionUse proxy.golang.org unless you have private modules or it's too slow. Running Athens adds complexity you don't need for public-only dependencies. But if your CI is in Asia, a local Athens instance might be 10x faster than hitting Google's servers.

Q

The proxy returns weird JSON errors, now what?

A

Check if you're hitting rate limits.

Some proxies throttle aggressive CI systems. GitHub's API limits can also cause upstream fetch failures. The error messages are usually garbage

  • look at HTTP status codes instead.My favorite cryptic error: ENOENT: no such file or directory when Athens can't write to its cache directory. Spent an hour thinking the module was broken.Here's how this stuff actually works and where it breaks in production.

Proxy Options (And Which Ones Actually Work)

Proxy

What It Is

When To Use It

Pain Points

proxy.golang.org

Google's free public proxy

Default for public modules only

No private repos, sometimes slow from Asia, goes down during Google outages

Athens

Self-hosted open source

Private modules + local caching

Memory leaks, crashes randomly, config is a nightmare

Goproxy.cn

China-based public proxy

You're in China and proxy.golang.org is blocked/slow

Only public modules, trust issues if you're paranoid

Artifactory

Enterprise artifact manager

You already pay JFrog for everything else

Costs more than your rent, sales team won't leave you alone

Nexus Repository

Enterprise repo manager

Multi-language shop, compliance requirements

Complex setup, expensive, Go support feels bolted-on

GitLab Go Proxy

Built into GitLab

Already using GitLab for everything

Half-baked feature, limited compared to Athens

How Proxies Actually Work (And Where They Break)

Go Proxy Flow

Here's how this stuff actually works when it breaks. The GOPROXY protocol is just 4 REST endpoints, but there are tons of ways it can screw up in production.

The 4 Endpoints That Matter

When you run go get github.com/gin-gonic/gin@v1.9.1, here's what happens:

  1. GET /github.com/gin-gonic/gin/@v/list - Lists all versions
  2. GET /github.com/gin-gonic/gin/@v/v1.9.1.info - Gets version metadata (timestamp, commit hash)
  3. GET /github.com/gin-gonic/gin/@v/v1.9.1.mod - Downloads just the go.mod file
  4. GET /github.com/gin-gonic/gin/@v/v1.9.1.zip - Downloads the full source code

Go is smart about it - it only downloads the .zip if it actually needs the source code. For dependency resolution, the .mod file is enough.

Where Things Go Wrong

Athens Architecture Overview

Memory Issues: Athens defaults to in-memory caching, which is fast but dangerous. I've seen it eat 8GB of RAM caching large modules like Kubernetes libraries. Always configure disk storage:

## athens config
storage:
  type: disk
  disk:
    rootPath: /var/lib/athens

Authentication Nightmares: Getting Athens to work with private GitHub repos is painful. You need to configure:

  • SSH keys or personal access tokens
  • Proper GOPRIVATE settings
  • Authentication in Athens config
  • Network access from Athens to your Git server

The Athens auth docs are better than most, but it's still a pain.

Timeout Hell: Default timeouts are too long. If upstream is slow, your builds wait forever. Set shorter timeouts:

export GOPROXY=https://athens.yourcompany.com,https://proxy.golang.org,direct
## Add this to your Athens config
timeout: 30s

Performance Reality Check

Local Athens: Fast locally, maybe 30-80ms if you're lucky
proxy.golang.org from US: Couple hundred milliseconds on a good day
proxy.golang.org from Asia: Good luck, sometimes over half a second
Direct Git clone: 2-10 seconds (why proxies exist)

If you're building in CI a lot, that 500ms adds up fast. Local caching makes a huge difference.

Storage Costs Add Up Fast

Modules aren't small. Popular ones like:

  • k8s.io/kubernetes - 50MB+
  • github.com/aws/aws-sdk-go-v2 - 30MB+
  • Any module with vendored dependencies - easily 100MB+

Athens compresses modules but doesn't deduplicate common dependencies. Cache hundreds of module versions and you'll burn through storage fast. Cloud blob storage (S3, GCS) works but adds operational complexity.

Debugging Proxy Issues

When things break (and they will), check these in order:

  1. HTTP status codes: 404 = not found, 410 = retracted, 500 = proxy broken
  2. Athens logs: Usually show the real error (like "Git authentication failed")
  3. Network connectivity: Can Athens reach the upstream Git server?
  4. GOPROXY fallback: Is Go trying the next proxy in the list?

The most common issue I see: developers set GOPROXY=https://athens.company.com (no fallback) and when Athens goes down, all builds break. Always include fallbacks:

export GOPROXY=https://athens.company.com,https://proxy.golang.org,direct

What Actually Works in Production

Most successful setups I've seen:

  • Athens for private modules
  • proxy.golang.org for everything else
  • Disk storage, not memory
  • Multiple fallbacks in GOPROXY
  • Monitoring on Athens (it will crash)
  • Docker Desktop randomly stops working and nobody knows why

The "enterprise" solutions (Artifactory, Nexus) work but they're overkill unless you're already using them for other stuff. Athens covers 90% of use cases at 1% of the cost.

For more Athens setup examples, check this practical guide or the Athens releases page for the latest stable version. The Athens Docker Hub has pre-built images that work out of the box.

If you're having authentication issues with private repos, the Athens GitHub issues usually have solutions. Most problems are GOPRIVATE configuration or SSH key setup.

That covers the technical deep-dive - now let's wrap up with the resources you'll actually need to implement and maintain a Go proxy setup.

Resources That Actually Help (Skip the Marketing BS)